Introduction
The Bible does not explicitly address psychological concepts like attachment styles. However, it does offer principles and perspectives that can intersect with them. Attachment theory, developed by British psychiatrist John Bowlby (1907–1990), describes how early relationships with caregivers can shape our patterns of relating to others throughout life. There are four styles of attachment: secure, anxious preoccupied, dismissive avoidant, and fearful avoidant. Here are some theological concepts that intersect with attachment styles:
God as a secure base: In attachment theory, a "secure base" is a reliable source of comfort and security from which a person can explore the world. Christians view God as their ultimate secure base, providing steadfast love, acceptance, and support. This view could promote a secure attachment style, where individuals feel confident in their relationships and have a healthy view of themselves and others.
Sin & brokenness: However, we cannot overlook the reality of human brokenness. From a Christian perspective, sin refers to human brokenness and the propensity to hurt ourselves and others. This brokenness can manifest in insecure attachment styles, such as anxious preoccupied, dismissive avoidant, or fearful avoidant, which may stem from past relational wounds or distorted views of self and others.
Redemption & healing: The Christian story does not end with brokenness. Christianity offers the hope of redemption and healing through the transformative power of God's love and grace. Individuals struggling with insecure attachment styles may find healing through spiritual practices, therapy, and supportive Christian communities that emphasize forgiveness, reconciliation, and restoration.
Community & belonging: Christianity emphasizes the importance of community and belonging within the body of Christ. Secure attachment styles are often associated with healthy relationships and belonging. Engaging in a Christian community, where individuals experience love, acceptance, and support, can promote secure attachment and emotional well-being.
Steadfast love: At the heart of Christian theology lies the radical notion of God's steadfast love (Greek: agapē; G26)—a love that knows no bounds and extends to all, regardless of merit or worthiness. This divine love serves as a counter-narrative to the messages of shame and unworthiness that often underlie insecure attachment styles, offering a vision of acceptance and belonging grounded in grace. God's love can challenge negative internal working models associated with insecure attachment styles. Understanding and experiencing God's love may help individuals develop more positive views of themselves and others, leading to greater relationship security.
Compassion & empathy: Finally, Christian theology calls us to embody the virtues of compassion and empathy—to bear one another's burdens and to walk alongside each other in love (see Gal. 6:2). Through acts of kindness, forgiveness, and selflessness, we cultivate secure attachments characterized by responsiveness to the needs and emotions of others. Empathy and compassion can promote secure attachment styles characterized by responsiveness to others' needs and feelings.
Secure Attachment in the Bible
Throughout the Bible, God is a loving and dependable presence. Psalm 18:2 declares, "The LORD is my rock, my fortress and my deliverer; my God is my rock, in whom I take refuge, my shield and the horn of my salvation, my stronghold." Just as a securely attached individual feels safe and supported by their caregiver, believers find security in God's unwavering love and protection. The scriptures emphasize God's steadfast and unfailing love for humanity. Paul's assurance to us in Romans illustrates this: "For I am convinced that neither death nor life, neither angels nor demons, neither the present nor the future, nor any powers, neither height nor depth, nor anything else in all creation, will be able to separate us from the love of God that is in Christ Jesus our Lord" (Rom. 8:38-39). This affirmation of God's steadfast love mirrors the sense of safety and acceptance experienced in secure attachment relationships.
Christian fellowship and community play a vital role in believers' lives. Luke described the early Christians who devoted themselves to teaching, fellowship, sharing meals, and prayer (see Acts 2:42-47). This sense of belonging and support within the Christian community reflects the importance of social connections in fostering secure attachment. The Bible is replete with stories of God's healing and redemption. Jesus' ministry, in particular, is marked by acts of healing and restoration, both physical and emotional. The prophet Isaiah spoke of God's mission to "bind up the brokenhearted" and "comfort all who mourn" (see Isa. 61:1-3). Through Christ, believers find hope for healing from past wounds and experiences that may affect their attachment styles. Christian teachings exhort believers to love one another as Christ loved them (see John 13:34-35). This includes demonstrating empathy, compassion, and forgiveness—the building blocks of secure attachment relationships. By imitating Christ's love in their interactions with others, believers can cultivate secure attachments characterized by trust, reciprocity, and emotional intimacy.
Joseph son of Jacob exemplified a secure attachment style. Despite facing numerous trials and challenges throughout his life, Joseph remained steadfast in his faith and exhibited resilience, adaptability, and emotional maturity. Joseph's secure attachment is evident in several aspects of his life story. He maintained a strong connection with God throughout his trials, trusting in divine guidance and remaining faithful even in difficult circumstances. Despite being betrayed by his brothers and sold into slavery, Joseph eventually forgave them and sought reconciliation when they came to him in need during a famine. This demonstrates his ability to maintain healthy relationships and forgiveness, qualities often associated with secure attachment. He displayed emotional stability and resilience, even when facing unjust treatment and adversity. He remained composed and maintained a positive outlook, which suggests a secure sense of self-worth and emotional security. Throughout his life, Joseph demonstrated empathy, compassion, and the ability to form meaningful connections with others, such as his interactions with Potiphar, Pharaoh, and his own family members. Overall, Joseph's story reflects many characteristics of a securely attached individual, including a strong sense of self, the ability to form and maintain healthy relationships, and resilience in the face of adversity (see Gen. 37–50).
Anxious Preoccupation in the Bible
Several passages of scripture address anxiety, worry, and relationships, which could be relevant to understanding and managing an anxious preoccupied attachment style. In his letter to the Philippians, Paul wrote: "Do not be anxious about anything, but in every situation, by prayer and petition, with thanksgiving, present your requests to God. And the peace of God, which transcends all understanding, will guard your hearts and your minds in Christ Jesus" (4:6-7). This verse encourages believers to bring their worries to God in prayer, trusting him to provide peace and comfort in times of anxiety. Likewise, Jesus teaches us about the futility of worrying about material needs, stating that God cares for his creation and will also care for his people. He encourages trust in God's provision (see Matt. 6:25-34).
In his first letter, Peter wrote, "Cast all your anxiety on him because he cares for you." This verse emphasizes the care and concern God has for individuals, inviting them to surrender their worries to him (1 Pet. 5:7). In Proverbs, King Solomon warned, "Anxiety weighs down the heart, but a kind word cheers it up" (12:25). This lesson acknowledges the heavy burden of anxiety but also suggests the power of kindness in alleviating it. While these passages do not explicitly address attachment theory, they offer wisdom and guidance on dealing with anxiety and finding security in one's relationship with God. Individuals with an anxious preoccupied attachment style might find comfort and support in these biblical teachings as they navigate their relational challenges and seek to find peace.
Leah, the first wife of Jacob, exemplified traits of anxious preoccupied attachment. Her story (see Gen. 29–31) portrays her deep longing for love and validation, coupled with feelings of insecurity and inadequacy. Leah's desperate need for love begins with her father, Laban, tricking Jacob into marrying her instead of her sister Rachel, whom Jacob loved. This sets the stage for Leah's constant desire for Jacob's affection and validation. Throughout her marriage to Jacob, Leah desperately tries to win his love and approval. She bears him many children, hoping each time that it will make Jacob love her more. However, her efforts are driven more by a need for validation than a genuine desire for motherhood. Leah's sense of self-worth seems to be tied to Jacob's affection for her, and she constantly compares herself to her sister Rachel, who is favored by Jacob. This comparison exacerbates her feelings of insecurity and inadequacy. Leah's emotional state is often turbulent, as she oscillates between moments of hope and despair based on Jacob's interactions with her. Her happiness is dependent on his external validation rather than internal sources of security. At times, Leah resorts to manipulation and bargaining in her attempts to win Jacob's love, such as when she trades mandrakes with Rachel in exchange for him spending the night with her. While Leah's story does not explicitly mention attachment theory, her behavior and emotional struggles align with the characteristics of anxious preoccupied attachment, characterized by a fixation with relationships, a fear of abandonment, and a constant need for reassurance and validation.
Dismissive Avoidance in the Bible
In the Bible, we find several examples of individuals who distance themselves emotionally or physically from others due to fear, shame, or a desire for independence. Jonah is an example because he initially tried to avoid God's command by fleeing in the opposite direction (see Jonah 1–4). His actions could be interpreted as a form of avoidance or dismissal of attachment to God's will. Similarly, in the New Testament, we see instances where characters struggle with attachment-related issues. For instance, the story of the rich young ruler who walks away from Jesus when faced with the challenge of giving up his wealth (see Matt 19:16-22) could be seen as an example of dismissive behavior driven by attachment to material possessions. While the Bible does not use modern psychological terminology, it does contain narratives and teachings that touch on themes relevant to attachment theory, including avoidance of intimacy, fear of dependency, and self-reliance.
King Saul displayed behaviors that align with the dismissive avoidant attachment style, characterized by a reluctance to form close emotional bonds and a tendency to distance oneself from others. He often struggled with emotional intimacy, even with his own family members and close advisors. Saul had difficulty expressing vulnerability and trusting others with his emotions. His leadership was marked by insecurity and a fear of losing control. Saul became increasingly paranoid about threats to his kingship, leading him to alienate potential allies and advisors. His relationship with David, who later became king, exemplifies the avoidance of intimacy. Despite David's loyalty and success, Saul viewed him as a threat and repeatedly attempted to kill him, rather than fostering a healthy and supportive relationship (see 1 Sam. 18–19). Saul often relied on his own judgment rather than seeking guidance or support from others, including from the prophet Samuel (see 1 Sam. 13) This self-reliance contributed to his downfall, as Saul failed to heed wise counsel and make decisions in the best interests of his kingdom. While the Bible does not explicitly use psychological terminology like "dismissive avoidant attachment," the character of Saul illustrates many of the behavioral patterns associated with this attachment style. His struggles with trust, intimacy, and emotional regulation serve as a cautionary tale about the consequences of rejecting meaningful connections with others.
Fearful Avoidance in the Bible
The Bible includes narratives and characters that exhibit behaviors and experiences reminiscent of the fearful avoidant attachment style. Individuals with this attachment style often desire close relationships but are simultaneously afraid of intimacy and have difficulty trusting others. They may oscillate between seeking closeness and withdrawing when they feel overwhelmed or vulnerable. The scriptures address themes of fear, trust, intimacy, and reliance on God that we could also relate to fearful avoidant attachment. There are numerous instances where characters express fear and struggle with trust. For example, the Israelites' fear and lack of trust in God's provision during their journey through the wilderness (see Exod. 16:2-3) demonstrate the human tendency to oscillate between seeking security and withdrawing due to fear and uncertainty. The Bible emphasizes the importance of intimate connection and reliance on God for comfort, guidance, and security. Psalms, in particular, are filled with expressions of longing for intimacy with God and finding refuge in Him during times of distress (see Ps. 23:1-4; 27:1-5). Scripture also offers narratives of healing and restoration, highlighting the possibility of overcoming attachment-related struggles through faith and spiritual growth. For instance, the story of Jacob's transformation after wrestling with God (see Gen. 32:22-32) can be seen as a metaphor for overcoming fear and finding healing in a relationship with God. While individual relationships with God are emphasized in the Bible, there are also teachings on the importance of community and support from others. The New Testament, in particular, emphasizes the concept of the church as a supportive community where believers can find encouragement, accountability, and love (see 1 Thess. 5:11; Heb. 10:24-25). While the Bible does not explicitly address fearful avoidant attachment, its teachings and narratives provide insights into the human experience of fear, trust, intimacy, and reliance on God and others. These timeless principles can offer guidance and comfort to individuals navigating attachment-related struggles in their lives.
Jacob is a biblical character who exhibits traits of fearful avoidant attachment. He desired close relationships, particularly with his father, Isaac, and later with his wife, Rachel. Jacob sought intimacy and connection but struggled with feelings of inadequacy and fear of rejection. Despite his desire for intimacy, Jacob also exhibited a fear of closeness. He manipulated his brother Esau and deceived his father to obtain his brother's birthright and blessing, demonstrating a reluctance to engage in authentic and honest relationships (see Gen. 26:34-28:9). Jacob's experiences with betrayal and deception, such as Laban tricking him into marrying Leah instead of Rachel (see Gen. 29), contributed to his difficulty trusting others. This lack of trust led him to adopt defensive strategies to protect himself from further hurt, such as manipulation and deceit. Throughout his life, Jacob experienced moments of seeking closeness with God and others, as well as periods of withdrawal and isolation. For example, he wrestled with God at Peniel, seeking a blessing and reconciliation, but also spent time alone in contemplation and reflection (see Gen. 32:22-32). While the Bible does not explicitly categorize characters like Jacob according to attachment styles, his experiences and behaviors reflect themes commonly associated with fearful avoidant attachment. His story serves as a nuanced exploration of the complexities of human relationships and the struggle to find a balance between intimacy and independence.
Attachment Styles in Christian Music
Secure attachment in Contemporary Christian Music (CCM) revolves around themes of love, trust, and faithfulness. These songs reflect themes of love, trust, and security in the context of a relationship with God, which can resonate with individuals seeking to understand and experience secure attachment in their spiritual journey. Here are a few songs that embody elements of secure attachment:
Anchor by Skillet—This song speaks about finding stability and security in challenging times, which is a fundamental aspect of secure attachment. The lyrics convey a sense of being grounded and supported, even amidst adversity.
Love Broke Thru by TobyMac—This song explores the transformative power of love and how it can break through barriers. Secure attachment is built on trust and openness, and love breaking through barriers can symbolize overcoming obstacles to form secure relationships.
Oceans (Where Feet May Fail) by Hillsong United—While this song emphasizes stepping out in faith and trusting God's guidance, it also conveys the sense of security that comes from knowing God is always present, holding us through life's challenges.
Strong Tower by Kutless—With lyrics that describe God as a refuge and stronghold in times of trouble, this song conveys the sense of safety and protection that characterizes secure attachment relationships.
Trust in You by Lauren Daigle—Through lyrics that express surrender and reliance on God's plan, this song conveys the security found in trusting his guidance and provision, even in times of uncertainty.
Anxious preoccupied attachment is characterized by a desire for closeness and fear of abandonment or rejection. In the realm of CCM, songs that convey feelings of longing, insecurity, or seeking validation could resonate with individuals experiencing this attachment style. These songs convey the emotions and struggles associated with anxious preoccupied attachment, offering comfort, reassurance, and a reminder of God's unfailing love and presence in the midst of life's challenges. Here are some songs that reflect elements of anxious preoccupied attachment:
Even If by MercyMe—This song addresses the struggle of maintaining faith in the face of adversity, expressing the longing for God's presence and assurance, even when circumstances seem overwhelming.
He Knows by Jeremy Camp—With lyrics that acknowledge the pain and struggles of life, this song emphasizes God's understanding and compassion, offering comfort and reassurance in his presence.
Hold Me Now by RED—This song expresses vulnerability and a longing for God's comfort and guidance in times of struggle, reflecting the anxious need for support and reassurance.
I Am Not Alone by Kari Jobe—While this song conveys reliance on God's presence and strength, it also addresses feelings of fear and uncertainty, expressing the longing for assurance and companionship.
Me without You by TobyMac—This song reflects on the emptiness and longing that can come from feeling disconnected or separated from a loved one. The lyrics express a dependence on the other person for fulfillment and happiness, which could resonate with anxious preoccupied attachment.
Dismissive avoidant attachment is characterized by a tendency to suppress emotions and avoid intimacy or closeness in relationships. While the themes of CCM may not explicitly address dismissive avoidant attachment, their themes of independence, self-reliance, and resilience may resonate with people who identify with this attachment style. Here are some songs that might resonate with those experiencing dismissive avoidant attachment:
Awake & Alive by Skillet—This song encourages listeners to break free from limitations and live life to the fullest. While not explicitly related to attachment, its themes of self-reliance and autonomy could appeal to individuals with dismissive avoidant attachment tendencies.
Beyond Me by TobyMac—This song speaks to the feeling of being overwhelmed and the desire to let go of control. While primarily about surrendering to a higher power, its themes of independence and self-reliance may resonate with individuals exhibiting dismissive avoidant attachment tendencies.
Stronger by Mandisa—This song speaks to overcoming challenges and adversity through God's strength, reflecting themes of resilience and self-sufficiency that align with dismissive avoidant attachment tendencies.
What Faith Can Do by Kutless—While primarily about the power of faith to overcome challenges, the song's message of inner strength and resilience may appeal to individuals with dismissive avoidant attachment tendencies who prefer to handle difficulties independently.
Your Love Never Fails by Jesus Culture—This song celebrates God's steadfast love and faithfulness, but the focus on God's reliability and constancy might appeal to individuals who prioritize stability and predictability in relationships.
Fearful avoidant attachment is characterized by a conflicting desire for closeness and fear of rejection or harm in relationships. Individuals with this attachment style often struggle with intimacy and trust. While explicit portrayals of fearful avoidant attachment may be less common in CCM, some songs may indirectly touch upon themes of fear, insecurity, and the struggle for intimacy. Here are a few songs that might resonate with individuals experiencing fearful avoidant attachment:
Broken Vessels (Amazing Grace) by Hillsong Worship—While this song celebrates God's grace and redemption, the acknowledgment of brokenness and the longing for healing may resonate with individuals struggling with fear and insecurity.
Control (Somehow You Want Me) by Tenth Avenue North—This song grapples with feelings of insecurity and surrendering control to God, reflecting the internal conflict and desire for closeness amidst fear of vulnerability.
The Hurt & the Healer by MercyMe—With lyrics that address pain and brokenness, this song offers hope and healing through God's love, acknowledging the struggle with fear and the need for redemption.
I Just Need U by TobyMac—This song explores themes of redemption, forgiveness, and the steadfast love of God. The message of acceptance and belonging may resonate with individuals experiencing fear of rejection or unworthiness.
Whispers in the Dark by Skillet—This song explores themes of longing, uncertainty, and the desire for connection. The lyrics convey a sense of vulnerability and a yearning for reassurance, which are common traits of fearful avoidant attachment.
Conclusion
In conclusion, while attachment theory provides valuable insights into the dynamics of human relationships, Christian theology offers a deeper dimension by grounding our understanding of attachment in the context of divine love and redemption. Integrating psychological understanding with spiritual principles can provide a holistic approach to realizing and promoting healthy relationships and emotional well-being from a Christian perspective. By embracing the truths of God's love, seeking healing from past wounds, and fostering nurturing relationships within the Christian community, we can cultivate secure attachments that reflect the transformative power of grace.
Prayer
Blessed are you, LORD our God, King of the universe; you keep them in perfect peace whose minds are stayed on you because they trust in you. We trust in you forever because you, Lord God, are our everlasting rock; through Jesus the Messiah our Lord, who lives and reigns with you and the Holy Spirit, one God now and forever. Amen.
Bibliography
The Book of Common Prayer. Huntington Beach, CA: Anglican Liturgy Press, 2019. p. 73. https://bcp2019.anglicanchurch.net/wp-content/uploads/2019/08/BCP2019.pdf.
Bowlby, John. A Secure Base: Parent-Child Attachment and Healthy Human Development. New York: Basic, 1988.
⸻. Attachment and Loss: Vol. 1: Attachment. Second ed. New York: Basic, 1983.
Cassidy, Jude, and Phillip R. Shaver, eds. Handbook of Attachment: Theory, Research, and Clinical Applications. Third ed. New York: Guilford, 2016.
Greggo, Stephen P., and Sisemore, Timothy A. Counseling and Christianity: Five Approaches. Christian Association for Psychological Studies Books. Downers Grove, IL: IVP Academic, 2012.
Grenz, Stanley J. Theology for the Community of God. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2000.
Knabb, Joshua J., Eric L. Johnson, M. Todd Bates, and Timothy A. Sisemore. Christian Psychotherapy in Context: Theoretical and Empirical Explorations in Faith-Based Mental Health. First ed. New York: Routledge, 2019.
Lucado, Max. Grace: More than We Deserve, Greater than We Imagine. Nashville: Thomas Nelson, 2014.
Mayfield, Krispin. Attached to God: A Practical Guide to Deeper Spiritual Experience. Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 2022.
Nouwen, Henri J. M. Reaching Out: The Three Movements of the Spiritual Life. New York: Image, 1986.
Smedes, Lewis B. Shame and Grace: Healing the Shame We Don't Deserve. San Francisco: HarperOne, 2009.
Strobel, Lee. The Case for Grace: A Journalist Explores the Evidence of Transformed Lives. The Case for ... Series. Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 2015.
Tozer, A. W. The Pursuit of God. Bloomington, MN: Bethany House, 2013.
Vanier, Jean. Becoming Human. Mahwah, NJ: Paulist, 2008.
Comments